Dead man walking matthew poncelet essay

Banks Bluevale English 7 years, 6 months ago Many people have very strong feelings about the use of capital punishment.

Capital Punishment in Dead Man Walking

This conversation tells the viewer that not all Christians are opposed to the death penalty — in fact, many Christians, whether situated in the Bible Belt or not, have a strong belief in the death penalty.

Once he faces the crimes he committed, he can die Dead man walking matthew poncelet essay dignity and receive redemption for taking responsibility of his sins. Many people feel that the death penalty is immoral and it should not be used; however I feel completely opposite.

His eyes open for the final time, and he is pronounced dead. After 10 years of costly legal appeals, all at taxpayer expense, their attacker was put to death. In my opinion, this movie is too compassionate towards Matthew Poncelet for murdering those two innocent people.

This certainly influences the viewer towards the anti-death penalty stance. From insight into her background and Christian upbringing Sister Helen is able to see and feel for Matthew as a person and not as an object of " Because clips of his crime are shown between clips of his execution, our opinions sway back and forth between anti- and pro-death penalty, just as they do throughout the whole film — we begin to empathise with Poncelet, and then he does something or something is revealed that turns us against him.

Sister Helen felt compassionate towards Matthew because of the person he had become through getting to know her and understand what she believed and wanted.

Poncelet is also the victim of bad politics which is another reason why he should not have been executed. Even though I support the death penalty, I still feel that the movie accurately described what life on death row was like for Matthew Poncelet.

Delacroix and the Percies. Before the scene begins, we are shown, between dialogues, the clock in the hall — every hour, on the half hour, until Delacroix, and asks for forgiveness, and then the Percies, and tells them that he hopes his death brings some relief to their lives.

The second time Prejean talks to Poncelet about the truth, it is clear that Poncelet understands what Prejean means. He is on death row because he murder two innocent people. One of the strongest techniques Robbins uses to give the viewer a feeling of precision is the shots of the clock.

Death is something we avoid in our minds with the hope that it will not touch us. From the beginning of the execution scene, Prejean is wearing black.

How to cite this page Choose cite format: Finally, if killing is considered immoral, this should include death-row murderers, and the State should not be in the business of killing people.

I believe that capital punishment is a fair sentence for a murderer to receive.

Dead Man Walking

This means a lot to her because she has seen Matthew the person no longer Matthew the monster. I feel that the movie is totally wrong when it suggests that Matthew Poncelet is on death row because he was poor.

Poncelet, however, is wearing a white t-shirt, when he had previously been wearing blue overalls. Thus, Matthew Poncelet should only have been sentenced to life for his terrible crimes. When Poncelet finally shows remorse and acknowledges his guilt, I saw him as a human being instead of the monstrous killer he was.

Matthew was always lonely and only cared about number one Himself. When such an event takes place we want revenge. The movie Dead Man Walking looks at all these complex issues surrounding capital punishment and forces its audience to take sides.

This compassion is crucial to the total change in ideals and morals that Matthew has now After knowing Sister Helen. She became a nun to give back to the community which gave her good Christian morals and values.

He knows what he did was terribly wrong and hopes his death will give the families the relief they need for the murder of their children.

After his release, he shot and killed an elderly man and his wife on their farm in eastern Washington State. In my opinion, once he took responsibility for his heinous acts arid faced the truth; he should be able to seek forgiveness. People should not receive the death penalty simply because they grew up in poverty.

After one of the flashbacks, we see Poncelet lying unconscious through the glass of the viewing room. There is a wedding ring on her finger, symbolising her marriage to Christ.

Because the whole film is shot from the point of view of Helen Prejean, we have the same attitude towards Poncelet as Prejean does — if Poncelet does something to make Prejean angry, we too feel less sympathetic towards him and his position, and if Prejean gets emotionally close to Poncelet, we sympathise with him more — hence we feel closest to him as he is dying.

Throughout the film, we see the relationship between Prejean and Poncelet develop — this is shown not only by their emotions, but by the physical barriers between them.

We do not, however, see the viewers reflected in the glass, but we see the faces of Hope Percy and Walter Delacroix.

For instance, he is not given another trial when his new lawyer explains to a judge that Poncelet did not receive a proper defense at his original trial.Based on the movie "Dead Man Walking" (). If you think that Matthew Poncelet, the main character, should be put to death, make as forceful an argument as you can for why he should not be put to death, and then show why this argument is, ultimately, unpersuasive.

The film "Dead Man Walking" raised an important ethical issue about whether a convicted criminal on death row should be allowed to have a spiritual advisor. I think the moral issue of the movie revolves around whether a spiritual advisor, such as a nun, should lend comfort or support to a death row inmate, such as Matthew Poncelet.4/4(1).

Dead Man Walking Paper

Dead Man Walking In the movie Dead Man Walking a story is told about a man put on death row, Matthew Poncelet (Seann Penn), who gains the company and friendship of a nun, Sister Helen Prejeon (Susan Sarandon). Analysis of Dead Man Walking, Free Study Guides and book notes including comprehensive chapter analysis, complete summary analysis, author biography information, character profiles, theme analysis, metaphor analysis, and top ten quotes on classic literature.

“Dead Man Walking” Watching the movie “Dead Man Walking” helped me to get a better understanding of the death this movie, there are many reasons why a person could or “should” be for the death penalty and why others might be against it.

Dead Man Walking is a film based on the book of the same name - it recounts the experiences of Sister Helen Prejean, a nun from Louisiana. It focuses on her relationship with Matthew Poncelet, a convicted murderer on Death Row.

Dead man walking matthew poncelet essay
Rated 5/5 based on 16 review